How to Choose Leather Scrap Grades: A Beginner-Friendly Guide

When you’re working with leather scraps, choosing the right grade can make the difference between a high-quality finished project and a frustrating crafting experience. Whether you’re making earrings, wallets, keychains, patches, or small leather goods, understanding how to select the best scrap leather will help you save time, money, and materials.

This guide breaks down what leather scrap “grades” mean, how to pick the right ones for your projects, and how common colors like brown leather and black leather differ in performance. We'll also cover how to evaluate leather pieces, leather remnants, and leather offcuts so you know exactly what to look for when shopping.

What Are Leather Scrap Grades?

Leather “grading” is simply a way to describe the quality, usability, and appearance of the leather. Because scraps and offcuts come from different parts of the hide, not all pieces will look the same.

Here are the three most common grades used in the leathercraft world:

Grade A—Usable Scrap Leather

Grade A pieces come from clean, smooth areas of the hide with minimal marks.

Grade A is best for:

• Wallets
• Keychains
• Coasters
• Patches
• Jewelry
• Any product where a clean appearance is important

Common features:

• Very clean grain
• Few natural marks or scars
• Smooth texture
• Consistent thickness

If you're making items you plan to sell, Grade A genuine leather scraps are a reliable choice.

Grade B—Craft-Ready, Slightly Marked Leather

Grade B leather scraps include small imperfections that do not affect functionality. These pieces are popular among DIY makers because they balance quality and cost.

Great for:

• Earrings
• Small accessories
• Leather labels
• Patches
• Bracelets
• Keychains

Common traits:

• Natural markings
• Slight color variation
• Small wrinkles or grain inconsistencies

Grade B scraps are excellent for craft leather projects and allow makers to utilize pieces with natural character in their designs.

Grade C—Highly Varied, Budget-Friendly Leather Offcuts

Grade C pieces include more visible marks and a range of textures. They’re suitable for experimentation and beginner projects because they cost less.

Best uses:

• Prototyping
• Kids’ crafts
• Experimental designs
• Practice cutting and sewing

Common traits:

• Noticeable scars or blemishes
• Texture differences
• Varied shapes and thicknesses

These are still genuine leather, but appearance is less critical—perfect for learning or testing tools.

Thickness Matters Too: How to Choose the Right Weight

Aside from grade, the weight or thickness of your leather scraps also plays a big role.

Here’s a quick guide:

If you’re unsure, start with 3–4 oz leather pieces, which are the most versatile for beginner crafters.

Understanding Leather Colors & Finishes

Different colors of leather scraps behave differently depending on their finish.

Brown Leather

A classic, durable, and forgiving color. Provides good contrast when engraved or stamped.

Black Leather

Produces sharp, clean edges. Engraving may result in a gray tone instead of light.

Dyed Colors

Reds, greens, grays, and other tones look vibrant but may show scratches more easily.

Pull-Up Leather

Changes color when bent—suitable for rustic wallets and accessories.

Oiled Leather

Soft, flexible, and easy to work with; suitable for bracelets and straps.

Understanding finishes helps you pick the right leather remnants for your exact project.

---

Inspecting Leather Scraps Before You Buy

When reviewing a bundle or listing, check for:

Consistency of Thickness

Look for pieces that maintain thickness from edge to edge.

Clean Grain

For visible projects, look for smooth markings.

Minimal Loose Fibers

The back of the leather (suede side) should feel compact, not fuzzy.

Good Size Variety

You’ll want a mix of smaller and larger leather offcuts for different uses.

Color Quality

Look for rich saturation—important for brown leather and black leather.

Which Grade Should You Choose for Your Project?

Here are quick recommendations:

For earrings:

Use Grade A or B. Lightweight 2–3 oz pieces work best.

For hat patches:

Choose Grade A or B in 3–4 oz. Colors like brown and natural show the best engraving contrast.

For wallets:

Grade A preferred; 3–4 oz for card slots, 4–5 oz for outer panels.

For kids' crafts:

Grade C is budget-friendly and suitable for learning.

For coasters:

Grade A or B in 4–5 oz thickness.

Why Buying Leather Scraps Is a Smart Choice

Leather scraps are eco-friendly, affordable, and versatile. They help reduce waste from full hides and give crafters access to high-quality materials.

Scraps are ideal for:

• Jewelry
• Bookmarks
• Small goods
• Labels
• Repairs
• Practice

They’re an economical way to get started with leatherwork.

Resource: Learn More About Leather Types

For more in-depth information on leather quality and grades, check out external resources.